📋 Committee Meeting
City of Bellingham Hearing Examiner
← Back to All Meetings
Meeting Summary
The City of Bellingham Hearing Examiner heard an appeal from Nathan Gerber challenging the impound of his 2004 Toyota RAV4 from the 200 block of North Forest Street on February 25, 2025. The vehicle was towed from a residential parking zone after being found without a visible parking permit or visitor pass displayed.
The case highlights ongoing tensions between the city's residential parking enforcement and the practical challenges faced by college-age renters in multi-unit housing near Western Washington University. Gerber's residence at 225 North Forest Street houses 10 people across four separate units but is only allocated four parking permits and four visitor passes under city code.
Parking Code Compliance Officer Stephanie Mays testified that the city had received seven complaints about parking violations on three streets in the area between January 23 and February 19, 2025. Staff responded five times before scheduling a coordinated tow operation for February 25 that targeted more than 10 vehicles. Gerber's vehicle had received one prior ticket on February 19 before being towed.
Gerber acknowledged his car was legally subject to towing but argued the enforcement was excessive and that the city had failed to provide adequate tools for residents to demonstrate their legitimacy. He testified that his visitor pass had fallen to the floor of his vehicle during rainy weather the night before and he forgot to redisplay it. Hearing Examiner Sharon Rice will issue a written decision by March 24, 2025.
Study Guide
## MODULE S1: STUDY GUIDE
**Meeting ID:** BEL-HEX-2025-03-10
### Meeting Overview
The Bellingham Hearing Examiner conducted a vehicle impound appeal hearing on March 10, 2025, regarding Nathan Gerber's appeal of the impound of his 2004 Toyota RAV4 from North Forest Street on February 25, 2025.
### Key Terms and Concepts
**Hearing Examiner:** An independent attorney who conducts quasi-judicial hearings for the city, reviewing appeals and making legally binding decisions on matters like parking violations and impounds.
**Residential Parking Zone:** A designated area where only residents with valid permits or visitors with visible passes can park during specified hours (8 AM to 5 PM, Monday-Friday in this case).
**Visitor Pass:** A temporary parking permit that must be hung from the rearview mirror or placed on the dashboard, allowing non-residents to park in residential zones for short periods.
**Residential Parking Permit:** A sticker that goes on the rear bumper or rear window of a vehicle, registered to a specific address and license plate in the city's system.
**Tow Away Zone:** An area where vehicles can be immediately impounded if parked in violation of posted restrictions during enforcement hours.
**Civil Penalty:** The standard fine for parking violations, typically $30, separate from towing and storage costs.
**Automated License Plate Reader (ALPR):** Technology used by parking enforcement to scan license plates and check them against the database of valid permits.
**Appellant:** The person appealing a city decision - in this case, Nathan Gerber challenging the validity of his vehicle impound.
### Key People at This Meeting
| Name | Role / Affiliation |
|---|---|
| Sharon Rice | Hearing Examiner (contract attorney for Bellingham) |
| Stephanie Mays | Parking Code Compliance Officer II, City of Bellingham |
| Nathan Gerber | Appellant (resident appealing vehicle impound) |
| Ms. Bowker | Hearing Clerk |
### Background Context
This case arose from ongoing parking problems in a residential area near Western Washington University campus. The Cedar Street, North Forest Street, and North Garden Street neighborhoods have residential parking zones specifically to prevent students from parking on residential streets and walking to campus. Between January 23 and February 19, 2025, the city received seven complaints from residents about parking violations in this area.
The property at 225 North Forest Street is unique - it's a single house divided into four separate dwelling units, housing approximately 10 people total. The city has already made an exception by allowing this property to have four residential permits and four visitor passes instead of the standard two of each for single-family homes. This reflects the unusual nature of the property but still creates challenges when multiple residents have vehicles.
Nathan Gerber's vehicle was towed after he forgot to display his visitor pass, which had fallen to the floor while driving the night before due to visibility concerns. This was his second parking violation at this location.
### What Happened — The Short Version
Nathan Gerber's car was towed from North Forest Street on February 25, 2025, because his visitor parking pass wasn't visible. The night before, he had removed the pass from his rearview mirror because it blocked his view while driving in the rain, then forgot to put it back up when he parked at home.
The city had received seven complaints about parking violations in this neighborhood over the previous month. Parking enforcement had made several visits to remind people about the rules before finally calling in tow trucks. Gerber's vehicle had already received one ticket on February 19.
During the hearing, Gerber argued that the city's parking system was unfair to his building, which houses 10 people but only has 4 permits and 4 visitor passes. He requested the impound fee be waived and asked for long-term solutions including additional permits.
The city explained that permits can only be issued through the property owner, and the building already has more permits than normal due to its unique situation. The hearing examiner noted she has no authority to change city parking rules and encouraged Gerber to speak with city council about policy concerns.
### What to Watch Next
- The hearing examiner's written decision is due by March 24, 2025
- If Gerber wants to change parking policies, he would need to address Bellingham City Council
- The hearing examiner mentioned she includes impound appeal issues in her annual report to city council