📋 Committee Meeting
City of Bellingham Hearing Examiner
← Back to All Meetings
Meeting Summary
The City of Bellingham Hearing Examiner conducted a vehicle impound appeal hearing on February 12, 2025, regarding a Subaru towed from Jersey Street on January 31, 2025. The appeal challenged both the validity of the impound and the associated towing and storage fees totaling $819.14.
The case arose from escalating enforcement in the 900 block of Jersey Street, a residential permit parking zone. After receiving multiple complaints and issuing 20 tickets over two enforcement visits in January, city parking enforcement scheduled coordinated towing operations with Heston Hauling for January 31st. The appellants' vehicle was among three cars towed that day, having parked directly in front of a "Tow Away Zone" sign while enforcement officers were actively operating with their lights on.
Caleb Barville and Paige Yearton, both college students, acknowledged the parking violation occurred but contested the towing fees as excessive. They argued the 20-minute parking duration to drop off tools for ecological restoration work in the nearby Sehome Arboretum did not warrant the substantial financial penalty. The appellants also claimed confusion about city towing policies based on prior communication about abandoned vehicle procedures.
City staff testified that Jersey Street has been properly signed as a residential permit zone with tow-away enforcement for multiple years. Parking Code Compliance Officer Stephanie Mays detailed the progressive enforcement approach and explained the distinction between immediate towing in permit zones versus 72-hour waiting periods for abandoned vehicles on non-restricted streets. Towing operator Chris Heston confirmed all fees charged comply with Washington State-approved rates.
The hearing concluded without an immediate decision, with Hearing Examiner Sharon Rice required to issue a written ruling within 10 business days by February 27, 2025.
Study Guide
## MODULE S1: STUDY GUIDE
**Meeting ID:** BEL-HEX-2025-02-12
### Meeting Overview
City of Bellingham Hearing Examiner Sharon Rice conducted a vehicle impound appeal hearing on February 12, 2025. College student Paige Yearton challenged both the validity of her car being towed from Jersey Street and the $819 towing and storage fees charged by the city's contracted towing company.
### Key Terms and Concepts
**Hearing Examiner:** An independent attorney who works on contract for the city to hear appeals of administrative decisions. Sharon Rice serves in this role and has jurisdiction to overturn or uphold city parking enforcement actions.
**Residential Permit Zone (RPZ):** A designated area where only residents with permits or visitor passes can park. Jersey Street has a two-block residential permit zone that has been established for multiple years.
**Tow Away Zone:** A parking area where vehicles can be immediately impounded if they violate parking regulations. Unlike other violations that may require 72-hour notice, tow away zones allow immediate removal.
**State-Approved Towing Rates:** Regulated fees that towing companies must charge for impounded vehicles, set by Washington State Patrol and based on the consumer price index. These rates prevent price gouging but can still result in high costs.
**Burden of Proof:** In this appeal, the appellant (Paige Yearton) must prove that the impound and fees were inconsistent with city regulations. The hearing examiner cannot reduce fees just because they seem excessive.
**After Hours Release Fee:** An additional charge when vehicle owners retrieve their cars outside normal business hours, requiring staff to come in specially.
### Key People at This Meeting
| Name | Role / Affiliation |
|---|---|
| Sharon Rice | City of Bellingham Hearing Examiner (contract attorney) |
| Stephanie Mays | Parking Code Compliance Officer 2, City of Bellingham |
| Chris Heston | Owner, Heston Hauling and Heston Towing |
| Caleb Barville | Appellant's representative, WWU student, neighborhood resident |
| Paige Yearton | Vehicle owner, college student |
| Christy Bowker | Hearing Clerk (mentioned, not present) |
### Background Context
The Jersey Street residential permit zone exists because of parking pressure from people accessing the nearby Sehome Hill Arboretum. The city has established a two-block permit zone to preserve parking for residents. Over several weeks in January 2025, the city received multiple complaints about unpermitted parking in this zone. After issuing 20 tickets over two enforcement visits, parking officers scheduled a coordinated towing operation with five tow trucks.
This case highlights the tension between protecting neighborhood parking and the financial impact of enforcement on young adults. The appellants were using the area for community service work at the Arboretum through WWU's Ecological Restoration Club, which had contributed over 400 volunteer hours to invasive species removal. However, good intentions don't override parking regulations, and the hearing examiner must determine whether proper procedures were followed.
### What Happened — The Short Version
On January 31, 2025, Paige Yearton parked her Subaru on Jersey Street at 9:15 AM to drop off tools for an ecological restoration project. She parked directly in front of a "Residential Permit Parking - Tow Away Zone" sign without having a permit. City parking officers were already on scene with tow trucks arriving shortly after 9:30 AM. The car was photographed, documented, and towed within about 40 minutes.
The total cost was $819.14, including towing, one and a half days of storage, and an after-hours release fee when Yearton's mother (the registered owner) authorized retrieval. The appellants argued this was excessive for a 20-minute parking violation and that they had been previously told by city staff that cars had to sit 72 hours before towing.
City staff explained that the 72-hour rule applies to abandoned vehicles on regular streets, but residential permit zones with tow away signs allow immediate removal. The hearing examiner will issue a written decision within 10 business days.
### What to Watch Next
• Hearing Examiner decision due by February 27, 2025 - will determine if the tow was valid and if fees must be paid
• Appellants have obtained visitor permits to prevent future violations in their neighborhood
• This case may influence how the city communicates parking enforcement policies to residents
---